[quote author=Ralphis link=topic=398.msg3648#msg3648 date=1299394555]<br />Third, anyone that says RottKing was &quot;Comeback Player of the Year&quot; doesn&#039;t know much about IDL or is just following popular opinion. He was instrumental in his teams going to back to back conference championships in 2010?[/quote]<br /><br />While it&#039;s true he has been on a ton of decent teams the last few seasons, the reality is that he&#039;s been the major exploit for those teams. He&#039;s been the reason why they&#039;ve lost because of his inability to defend whereas this year, that hasn&#039;t been the case. He&#039;s returned close to his form of 4 years ago or so, when he was a fragging machine and you&#039;d be lucky to get past him. Sure, Dev qualifies for this, too, but I don&#039;t think anybody expected Dev to do poorly this season like they expected Rott to. Gilga also qualifies for this but the reason I selected Rott over Gilga is pretty much the same reason I selected him over Dev. Gilga is also having a fantastic season, he&#039;s not fragging as much as RottKing but he&#039;s still doing very well and he also makes one hell of a runner. Again, I expected this from Gilga. So that is why the award, in my opinion, should go to RottKing. If you don&#039;t like it, go make another bone-headed decision like making LB MVP! <br /><br />